A key component of results based management is performance measurement, which. However, our analysis also shows that implementing resultsbased approaches in agriculture is challenging because of the complexity of measuring and achieving results in the sector. Governments will continue to experience fiscal space challenges, the government. Using evaluation findings to generate lessons and increase the understanding of strengths, weaknesses and comparative advantages 7. Challenges to implementing resultsbased management in public.
Implementing resultsbased management in local government james e. What is wrong with results based management humentum. The major tenets of rbm are explored and examined against traditional implementationfocused public management systems. Pdf analyse current challenges faced by managers in. Part three explores the importance of the management function of rbm, focusing on managing for results. Implementing resultsbased management in the public sector. Governments will continue to experience fiscal space challenges, the government of zimbabwe decided to promote optimum utilisation of the scarce revenue streams that flow into the national fiscus. Implementing resultsbased management in the public.
From a results perspective, the implementation process is significant only in terms of what it leads to. See also paragraph 33, which stresses, resultsbased management, accountability and transparency of the united nations development system are an integral part of sound management. Integrating lessons learned and findings of selfevaluations, interpreting the information. Challenges and lessons in implementing resultsbased management. Building a results based management and evaluation system in colombia duration. Cedil the centre of excellence for development impact and learning, funded by dfid, has. Resultsbased management rbm, which has been implemented.
Approach rra as one of the tools for implementing results based management in the public service is therefore consistent with the focus on results, capacity enhancement and client ownership. Changing existing governance systems can be challenging, especially if communication of the changes, the reasons behind them, and the planned or expected results to be achieved are lacking. Resultsbased management is the technique most commonly used by donors and the ngo sector to assess programme effectiveness. In this regard, results based management provides a framework for addressing the 2030 agenda. This report documents the lessons learned by twelve government of canada initiatives that used the outcome management or costbenefit analysis techniques to demonstrate their value. Rbm, key principles, main elements, rationale processes and obstacles in. In fragile and conflictaffected states fcas, this can be further complicated by the involvement of international agencies and their relationships with country governments, as well as by. Straus swiss is an associate pr ofessor in the public administration pr ogram at north. Many of the key challenges are organizational challenges rather than technical. Jamaica environmental action program enact caribbean. Introduction united nations system organizations have been implementing resultsbased management since 2002. Common issues affecting monitoring and evaluation of large ilo projects strategies to address them by robert lahey the responsibility for opinions expressed in this document rests solely with the authors.
This policy statement consolidated the progress already. During the tenth stage lessons learnt and findings of selfevaluations. At the council meeting in may 2014, the gef secretariat foreshadowed the upgrading of the gef results based management rbm system in the action plan for implementing gef6 policy recommendations. Rapid results approach initiative management consultants. Building a resultsbased management and evaluation system in colombia. Challenges and lessons in implementing resultsbased. A robust system to ensure that key management decisions are based on results is critical to help the gef network achieve its objectives. The need to enhance public sector performance has become more urgent as governments face mounting demands on public expenditure, calls for. Linking performance measures to the policy or strategic framework is key 4. A customised resultsbased management regime is critical 2. Resultsbased management is a participatory and teambased approach to programme planning and focuses on achieving defined and measurable results and impact. Essence of resultsbased management in zimbabwe the. Actionable impact management choosing the right metrics actionable impact management highlights a datadriven process for impact measurement and assessment developed by sopact. Integrating performance information into budgeting, managing and reporting has become a common component of good public and notforprofit management.
Resultsbased management rbm is well entrenched as a management tool for international. Organisational approaches and challenges to implementing. This document is based on the unesco resultsbased programming, management and monitoring rbm guiding principles, unesco paris, bureau of strategic planning, january 2008, and translated into russian by the unesco cluster office in almaty 4 1. The content analysis of the project management body of knowledge guide showed that the guide defines lessons learned narrowly, primarily as a set of administrative, documented outputs. Results based management is a participatory and team based approach to programme planning and focuses on achieving defined and measurable results and impact. Challenges and lessons in results based management.
Introduction lessons learned from implementing resultsbased management at cida resultsbased management lessons learned. A discussion is provided of 12 key challenges to resultsbased management, identifying the challenge, noting the experience others have had in relation to the challenge and providing lessons and suggestions for dealing with them. This article concentrates on attempts by oecd countries to introduce. Challenges to the implementation of plap in primary. Implementing resultsbased management systems in zimbabwe. Pdf challenges and lessons in implementing resultsbased. Using performance information for internal management accountability, learning, resource allocation decisions including human resources management, and reporting to stakeholders and partners 79. Resultsbased management in the project and programme cycle. Assessment of ways to enhance resultsbased budgeting and. The role of human resource managers in results based. Integrating performance information into budgeting, managing and.
Results based management rbm is a tool for monitoring and managing the implementation of strategy favoured particularly by organisations and agencies that are part of or are linked to the united nations. The aim of rbm is to manage an intervention while trying to ensure. Resultsbased management in the united nations development. However, to vested interests, performance management is a subversive. It also documents a series of related best practices for effective outcome management from other jurisdictions that are in various stages of introduction and adoption of outcome management or equivalent. Challenges and lessons in implementing resultsbased management article pdf available in evaluation 1. Organisational approaches and challenges to implementing resultsbased management emastersatyork.
Lessons from six case studies international rescue. Develop and implement a project or programme monitoring framework andor. Undps approach to resultsbased management outputs and outcomes. Implementing agencies such as ngos or national government agencies are not alone in being puzzled or intimidated by the terms used in results based management, monitoring or evaluation. This article outlines the two major models of rbm, that is, the integrated resultsbased management system. The effective participation of the office of the prime. Rbm, key principles, main elements, rationale processes and obstacles in introducing results based management. Part four presents monitoring as an essential component for assessing results. Information about the capacity and level of development of resultsbased management in. A discussion is provided of 12 key challenges to results based management, identifying the challenge, noting the experience others have had in relation to the challenge and providing lessons and suggestions for dealing with them.
Challenges to results based approaches while widely applied in public service delivery health, education, water, infrastructure, etc. First, desired outcomes such as increased yields or incomes are highly variable and influenced by external conditions e. Challenges to the implementation of plap in primary schools. Rapid results initiatives taps into the human desire to succeed by creating real empowerment, motivation and innovation in working towards results.
I wish to acknowledge the technical leadership of the national planning authority for leading the technical process of developing this report. Implementing resultsbased management in the public sector of. Implementing resultsbased management in local government. Results, outcomes, results based management, implementation focused management, public management, accountability. In many jurisdictions, efforts to do so have been under way for many years, yet progress is usually seen as slow at best. The publication does not constitute an endorsement by the international labour organization. Information about the capacity and level of development of results based management in. Footnote 12 the auditor general of canadas implementing results based management. Lessons from the literature presents findings of best practices from across canada and other jurisdictions for developing performance measurement systems. Resultsbased management rbm is a tool for monitoring and managing the implementation of strategy favoured particularly by organisations and agencies that are part of or are linked to the united nations. The study investigated the benefits from rbm, problems being encountered and lessons from experience. Results based management in the united nations development system.
There are three major challenges that are specific to the agricultural sector. Resultsbased management and the 2030 agenda for sustainable. It is designed to improve programme delivery and strengthen management effectiveness, efficiency and accountability siddique, 2010. This noble goal is to be achieved through performance management, a key component of results based management system. Pdf challenges and lessons in resultsbased management. The aim of rbm is to manage an intervention while trying to ensure its relevance, efficiency, effectiveness, impact and. Performance management, also referred to as results based management, can be defined as a broad management strategy aimed at achieving important changes in the. Common issues affecting lessons learned monitoring and. In addition to assessing the progress and challenges, the analytical study makes forwardlooking recommendations taking into consideration the.
In rbm, inputs and the activities which transform them into outputs reflect the process of implementing projectsprogrammes4 rather than desirable end results in themselves. As part of its commitment to becoming more resultsoriented, cida introduced the policy statement on resultsbased management in cida in 1996. Define them at different levels, including outputs, outcomes and impact. It is common to see staff of both bilateral and multilateral donor agencies who are confused by what the jargon means. Rain has faced challenges related to implementing in partnership across two international ngos, finance and operational systems that. Lessons and challenges by teresa curristine teresa curristine is administrator in the budgeting and public expenditures division of the public governance and territorial development directorate, oecd. Lessons learned from implementing resultsbased management rbm in cida resultsbased management prepared by resultsbased management division performance and knowledge management branch june 1998 introduction executive summary i. Challenges and lessons in implementing results based management. Introducing resultsbased approaches in agriculture. Introduction united nations system organizations have been implementing results based management since 2002. Lessons from the literature introduction promoting favorable implementation conditions o organisational factors 1.
Preface it is said that if you do not know where you are going, any road will take you there. Identify clear and measurable results ie what a project aims to achieve. The report examines the progress and effectiveness in its implementation. Results based management a central feature of the reforms has been the emphasis on improving performance. Assessment of ways to enhance results based budgeting and assessment of the resource allocation system introduction 1. This report has been developed with contributions and support from both state and nonstate actors.
The 2030 agenda is a game changer and presents opportunities for the advancement of results based management in the united nations system. Lessons from implementing partners deepening democracy programmes dpp resultsbased management rbm approach, developed over the past two years, involves monitoring, collecting and evaluation of evidence of what is working, what isnt working in the. At the council meeting in may 2014, the gef secretariat foreshadowed the upgrading of the gef resultsbased management rbm system in the action plan for implementing gef6 policy recommendations. Report on results, lessons learned and best practices use of itcs to support rbm. If you are interested in learning more on your own about results based management, below are links to 50 results based management handbooks, guides and websites with other tools and opinions on results based management, related topics on planning and evaluation, and information on the donor agencies approaches to results based management. Resultsbased management rbm, which has been implemented successfully in the public sector in many developed countries, is a relatively new concept in developing countries. The purpose of this study is to explore challenges in the implementation of plap in the primary schools. The article reflects on challenges associated with rbm and draws.
A read is counted each time someone views a publication summary such as the title, abstract, and list of authors, clicks on a figure, or views or downloads the fulltext. Lessons and challenges oecd journal on budgeting v olume 5 no. Resultsbased management in the united nations development system. It in many respects is similar to the logical framework, a strategy implementation tool used extensively by nongovernmental organizations. The 2030 agenda is a game changer and presents opportunities for the advancement of resultsbased management in the united nations system. Implementing agencies such as ngos or national government agencies are not alone in being puzzled or intimidated by the terms used in resultsbased management, monitoring or evaluation. Assessment of ways to enhance resultsbased budgeting and assessment of the resource allocation system introduction 1. Jul 15, 2014 organisational approaches and challenges to implementing results based management emastersatyork. In this regard, resultsbased management provides a framework for addressing the 2030 agenda. The main challenges and difficulties faced by some of the organizations in trying to implement. The article focuses on the introduction of the new concept of resultsbased management rbm in zimbabwes public sector.
1480 302 1387 1656 1135 857 1012 1108 232 699 1486 1291 288 1371 1057 1084 470 458 1270 1538 1235 1200 638 268 295 277 1306 999 610